Granny Flat or Log Cabin Extension: Which Adds More Value to Your Home in 2025?

Why Irish Homeowners Are Expanding Smarter in 2025

Across Ireland, families are looking for space that works harder: somewhere quiet for work, a spot for teens to spread out, or a comfortable setup for a parent to live independently but nearby. The traditional answer was a full masonry extension. In 2025, the faster, cleaner answer is often timber-based: a well-specified log cabin extension that connects smoothly to the existing house, or a self-contained granny flat with its own kitchen and bathroom.

Both routes add real value, but they serve slightly different needs. One expands the day-to-day footprint of the main home; the other creates an independent mini-dwelling with privacy and flexibility. This guide looks at planning, costs, comfort and resale impact, so you can choose the path that suits your family and your budget—without getting bogged down in red tape.

Granny Flat vs Log Cabin Extension – What’s the Difference?

A quality timber system earns its keep in speed, predictability and finish. Prefabricated elements arrive weather-tight and go together quickly, which keeps disruption to a minimum and helps you lock in timelines—handy if you’re juggling school runs and work.

Loghouse Ireland, Bray Showroom, Horkans Garden Centre, Glen of the Downs, Bray, Co. Wicklow, A98 W3V8

Planning Permission & Regulations

Planning is where these two options diverge. A granny flat is typically treated as a self-contained unit. That means a fuller planning process and careful attention to services, access and compliance. Local authorities will look closely at drainage, parking and whether the unit could be used as a separate dwelling down the line.

A log cabin extension—especially when designed as an attached or properly sited detached room—can be more straightforward. In Ireland, some smaller detached garden structures can qualify as exempted development if they meet specific conditions around size, height, and distance from boundaries. Thresholds are commonly associated with figures such as 25 m² and 3 m, but criteria and interpretations vary. Always verify the current position with your local planning office or a competent professional.

Cost & Build Timeline Comparison

Costs vary with design, groundwork and finishes, but a like-for-like comparison helps frame expectations.

As a rough illustration, a well-specified 30 m² log cabin extension might land around the €35k–€45k mark, while a 30 m² granny flat, fully fitted with kitchen and bathroom, typically reaches €60k+ once services and compliance are factored in. The right choice comes down to how the space will be used, and how quickly you want to be in it.

Energy Efficiency & Heating Options

Whichever route you choose, comfort depends on the “fabric first” details: insulation, airtightness, and good glazing. Timber systems shine here. Engineered walls with continuous insulation, careful sealing around openings and A-rated windows keep heat where it belongs and make the space feel settled, rather than “on/off” hot and cold.

For heating, homeowners usually prefer simple, reliable electric options that respond quickly and are easy to control. EVRad ceramic radiators give steady, comfortable warmth with tidy wall-mounting and built-in thermostats. For premium underfoot comfort, electric underfloor heating can be added and set on a timer for morning and evening routines. If you have already read our heating guide (Best Heating Options for Your Garden Room), you’ll know that pairing the right-sized unit with clear schedules keeps running costs predictable.

• Specify quality floor, wall and roof insulation from the outset.
• Use 7-day schedules to warm the space before use and reduce setpoints when empty.
• Consider a small PV array to offset daytime electricity use where suitable.

Which Adds More Value to Your Home?

Value works differently depending on what you build. A compliant granny flat adds real appeal—it’s an independent space that works for rentals or having family close by, and buyers love the flexibility. One week it’s a home office, the next it’s where your parents stay, or extra room when friends visit. A log cabin does something different: it gives you more space in your actual house. The kind of space people really want—a bright room for the kids to play, somewhere quiet to work, or a proper TV room so your living areas don’t feel cramped. Plus, log cabins go up fast and look finished when they’re done, so you get the lifestyle benefit without months of chaos and disruption.

Either way, the details matter. Good storage, proper electrics, solid heating, and thoughtful touches make the space feel like a real room rather than an afterthought. That difference shows when you sell—buyers notice, and it shows in their offers.

Family & Lifestyle Use Cases

Granny Flat: independence without distance

Having a granny flat means your relative gets their own place, but you’re still there if they need you. They can do their own thing without feeling like they’re in the way. You could always rent it out later, too, if you wanted.

Log Cabin Extension: everyday life made easier

Kids can make noise without waking the whole house. You can have an office and actually close the door. The toys don’t end up everywhere. It just stops everything from feeling so packed in.

When Each Option Makes Sense

Related Extension Resources

• Prefabricated Extensions in Ireland — how prefab timber speeds up the build.
• Log Cabin Insulation Guide — fabric-first comfort and lower running costs.
• EVRad Ceramic Radiators — simple, reliable heating for year-round use.

Loghouse Ireland, Bray Showroom, Horkans Garden Centre, Glen of the Downs, Bray, Co. Wicklow, A98 W3V8

The 2025 Verdict & Next Steps

There’s no best answer for everyone—just what works for you. If you need a separate space and might rent it or have guests, a granny flat does the job. If you just need more room in the house—somewhere quiet for work, space for the kids that doesn’t mess up the living areas—a log cabin extension is better. Less disruption, more space.

Before you build anything, figure out what services you need, whether you need permission, what heating you want, and how long it’ll take. Sort that out first, and the building part is easier. When it’s done, it’ll just feel like it’s always been there.

FAQs